Welcome to my joke, unofficial judging of the entries
I'll just do the first 5 and do the rest later
Afterimage -
http://frhd.co/t/854317-r-ng-nhi-t-i
Ride: Ride seems a bit of a challenge but it's manageable (seeing it's a sh*tpost). I'd give it 6/10. There's really not much improvement you can do in such a small space.
In terms of detail (my standards of course), it's great. Though, my only nitpick is the background. Could've used more detail to rap the entire scene together. The rock formation look like an eyesore at first but the more you look at it is the more you see what's there. overall, it's good. I'll give a solid 8/10
For creativity, it looks creative as heck. I won't say nothing else cause it's a small track. Because it looks unfinished, I'll give a solid 8/10.
CK9C -
https://www.frhd.co/t/840631
This one is underplayed so I don't know how good the track is. Anyways, played it off account so I got a grasp.
Ride: The ride is quite slippery though it reminds me of my Drowned Cavern for the first MWCE. Ride doesn't really flow that well because of the tube, slippery and jagged parts. I'm thinking this was meant to be a trial but it's a good attempt. 3/10
Detail: Detail is scarce. But this dude is still learning so I'll give him some advice, here's some threads you can check out for detail |
https://community.freeriderhd.com/threads/free-rider-hds-track-making-compendium.13450/ | Sadly this is a contest and I have to judge accordingly. 2/10
Creativity: Quite creative I'll give you that. Could use more time to smooth out the ride and detail. More playtesting for more flow or fixing. Otherwise, good attempt 6/10
Eli
Lemme comeback to you on my lunch break. I don't want to get in trouble with my teacher if y'know what I mean ; )
Fluffysmack -
https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/852895-scrubby-2-0
Ride: Ride is very simple yet fun. There is a bit of issues with that first to second star transition but that is very easy to get around. Great job 8.5/10
Detail: I don't know what to say about this. From your previous entry for MWC1, this is just as good. Trees were done amazingly, theme is there, everything looks good. Love the mini waterfall in the corner and the use of white space is good. Gotta give you respect dude. 9.5/10
Creativity: I can't do this lol. The creativity and a clear theme is there. Well done dude! 9.5/10
Light_Sky -
https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/843944-contest-entry-desc
Ride: The ride isn't half bad. It does need smoothing out but it's manageable. Not much creativity though. 3/10
Detail: Sadly, barely any detail. Good attempt but it's not enough. Keep practising dude. 1/10
Creativity: Creativity is lacking. Could use more ride, more detail, more y'know... pizzazz. 2/10
Click to expand...