Stig's top 50 trackmakers of all time

edit: really though, nice list

 

Nice list, but personally, both you and Maple should be above lolz, maybe even Max.

 

Tbh why is Rey827 so high up? Sure, his first track was really good, but I dont think he should be in front of the likes of Max and Honza
Just my opinion

 

The quality of detail, aswell as rey's creative story idea from start to end, was all i needed to place him above.
His storyline is exceptional and i have not seen anything like it in a high quality track. I am doubtless that he is not of any lesser skill than those you mentioned.

I rate by quality of tracks, not quantity.

 

Fair enough I suppose, I can see why he is at the very least rated higher than Honza but I still feel that Magnum Opus trumps his track in terms of storyline, length, detail and originality. Sure some of Magnum Opus was sloppy but 90% of it was fantastic.
(Not to say that Reys track isnt original, just I believe that Max's only just trumps it)

 

Max' recent track magnus opus isn't the track who got him to this list, eventhough it is great. I'm not going to bother explaining deeply, but it is a detail oriented list, and detailwise it falls short because of its simplicity.

 

Okey dokey, thats fine. Just wanted to share my opinion

 

Why is phil so high up?

 

I miss anao ;-;

 

Man te moana was awesome

 

ight gotta ask, why is joekeene there? he has only one track so I wouldn't even really consider him a trackmaker, and it's flippin' horrible, even by classic standards.

 

WHERE THE FUCCCKKK IS MMI

 

not on this list
Crypt i included him because he made a cool detailed track before there was anything to branch off from. He is more original than anyone except lolz, when it comes to detail. i can agree that i placed him a bit high, but he once made a track on oml, very similar to rhey's track, but bigger. it never got on the db tho :s the start in tools of destruction, is an attempt to directly copy some parts in that track, except that it was 1000 times more epic.

 

Will this ever update when we have new good track makers?

 

Uggg... This list is so unacurate. Many of your picks are old authors, giving no respect to the players who stuck to the game. If you are going to do a list on older players from early frhd and canvas rider, say so and don't name your list the " best of all time" Also why did you put yourself as number 3????

 

It can't be inaccurate if it's an opinion

 

lol, amateur

 

Hes too humble for number one

 

Cataclysm i never knew u were thepenguins lol i guess it makes sense though

 

Also keked. Go stiggo