Log in

Feedback from featuring discussions

Discussion in 'Tracks' started by Ness, Feb 18, 2023.

Tags:

Page 9 of 19

Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

Elibloodthirst said: ↑

I'm voting yes.

Has everything classic and old school but still feels new. Really dig this, it's nostalgia coddled in with some relatively good rock detail.

It's like hawnks and brainchef with the same line vibes as when tfm broke through. I gotta admit though it's not perfect, ride isn't always consistent and has a bit of the powerline affect to it but I think it's still decent enough to gloss over this issue.
Click to expand...

Ness said: ↑

yea

I really dig the return to the classic detailing style, it's cool to see. it's done well and I don't have many notes about that. but I do think the ride is neglected here and I think some cleaning up would do some good. the mtb can cover it up a little bit, but the ride is glitchy and a little uncontrolled, only just held together by boosts and gravities. it's not a bad ride, and I think the layout is pretty nice, but just a little more care to keeping clean the physics lines that the bike touch would be my recommendation
Click to expand...

4 yea 0 nay

congratulations bro

Elibloodthirst, Jul 17, 2023

#161

OINKY, SirHuman01, qduhon and 7 others like this.
JacksofAmerica Member Official Author

Awarded Medals

This is awesome news! Thank you all for the support! Ness and Elibloodthirst

JacksofAmerica, Jul 17, 2023

#162

OINKY, SirHuman01, gun and 4 others like this.
SirHuman01 Well-Known Member Team Blob Official Author

JacksofAmerica said: ↑

This is awesome news! Thank you all for the support! Ness and Elibloodthirst
Click to expand...

Congrats! The track honestly deserved it. Enjoy the publicity it'll get now

SirHuman01, Jul 17, 2023

#163

OINKY and Azgr00 like this.
JacksofAmerica Member Official Author

Awarded Medals

thank you so much SirHuman01

JacksofAmerica, Jul 17, 2023

#164

OINKY, SirHuman01, gun and 2 others like this.
loge_0 ‮‮� VIP Team Truck Team Balloon Official Author

Awarded Medals

can i be updated on the current status on the vote of my track Miscellany Bunker? i know it was put up for a vote some time last month, but i think due to lack of activity i still haven't received the feedback from the voting (only 2 people votes on it from my knowledge). if there was feedback, id like to see it posted here, otherwise i suggest a re-vote soon now that the feat mods are slightly more active now, so I can get the most out of this process.

loge_0, Jul 30, 2023

#165

OINKY, dantexpress, Volund and 2 others like this.
OINKY Member Official Author

https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/954676-better-days

OINKY, Jul 31, 2023

#166
gun Forum Legend Team Blob Official Author

loge_0 said: ↑

can i be updated on the current status on the vote of my track Miscellany Bunker? i know it was put up for a vote some time last month, but i think due to lack of activity i still haven't received the feedback from the voting (only 2 people votes on it from my knowledge). if there was feedback, id like to see it posted here, otherwise i suggest a re-vote soon now that the feat mods are slightly more active now, so I can get the most out of this process.
Click to expand...

I'm in the same boat. I personally have no idea if https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/944357-forest-slopes was ever put up for any votes/feedback, but I would really love to get some feedback on this track and how it relates to the featuring criteria (if any lol), dont mind if it wasnt considered, but just if in the off-hand chance it was, id love to hear about it.

gun, Aug 2, 2023

#167

loge_0, Radio_Silence and Volund like this.
pssst Forum Legend Elite Author Team Blob Official Author

Awarded Medals

https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/955465-altruism

pssst, Aug 14, 2023

#168

pawflix, pinn, Elibloodthirst and 5 others like this.
MyrraWolf Well-Known Member Official Author

Awarded Medals

pssst said: ↑

https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/955465-altruism
Click to expand...

i lowkey thoghut that said https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/955465-autism

Last edited: Aug 19, 2023

MyrraWolf, Aug 14, 2023

#169

pawflix, Elibloodthirst and Volund like this.
Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

pssst said: ↑

https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/955465-altruism
Click to expand...

Yknow what.

Elibloodthirst, Aug 15, 2023

#170

SirHuman01 likes this.
Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

Altruism by KidCharlemange

Max007x said: ↑

Im not sure about featured, but its a great track with a lot of thought into the ride and I like that
Click to expand...

Ness said: ↑

while I'd love to see more of this kind of track, I personally don't see it being on par with the current standard of featured tracks. the ride layout is intriguing and the theme works great, the simplicity adds a lot to it, but without the art/detail being high level, it's not quite there.

loge's miscellany bunker is a better track with similar good qualities. that is to say, if we lowered our standards a little bit, I wouldn't mind featuring both. but with the standard we've set, it's a nay from me.
Click to expand...

Eryp said: ↑

cmon now, the ride is fun sure but the track is a bunch of floating platforms. if anything it reminds me of shelbylowry detail, and this comes nowhere close to the quality of her features.
Click to expand...

Elibloodthirst said: ↑

Just thought it was niche. ultimately no due to lack of complexity
Click to expand...

pinn said: ↑

yeah good points. I personally like this track more than some of the page 1 featured tracks, but that's ultimately irrelevant when there's an actual standard that needs to be maintained lol
Click to expand...

Votes: 1 YAY 5 NAY

Final Verdict: NAY

Elibloodthirst, Aug 23, 2023

#171

FIREBEATS, Volund, pawflix and 3 others like this.
loge_0 ‮‮� VIP Team Truck Team Balloon Official Author

Awarded Medals

loge_0 said: ↑

can i be updated on the current status on the vote of my track Miscellany Bunker? i know it was put up for a vote some time last month, but i think due to lack of activity i still haven't received the feedback from the voting (only 2 people votes on it from my knowledge). if there was feedback, id like to see it posted here, otherwise i suggest a re-vote soon now that the feat mods are slightly more active now, so I can get the most out of this process.
Click to expand...

any progress on this front? soz if im been a little annoying lol

loge_0, Aug 23, 2023

#172

Volund, dantexpress and TPlacella like this.
Ness Guest

loge_0 said: ↑

any progress on this front? soz if im been a little annoying lol
Click to expand...

no progress sadly, vips (including myself) haven't been writing criticism or advice as often as we were before. but I'll personally write something up for you within a few days since I'm a big fan of the track

Ness, Aug 23, 2023

#173

CHARREDLIZARD21, pawflix, loge_0 and 5 others like this.
loge_0 ‮‮� VIP Team Truck Team Balloon Official Author

Awarded Medals

Ness said: ↑

no progress sadly, vips (including myself) haven't been writing criticism or advice as often as we were before. but I'll personally write something up for you within a few days since I'm a big fan of the track
Click to expand...

sick, cheers man

loge_0, Aug 24, 2023

#174

pawflix likes this.
Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

NO feedback was given at the time loge_0

0-3

Pros
Intelligent layout
Looks relatively fun to play (again idk though)
Really clean in some places

Cons
Too difficult for the average user (myself included I'm shocking)
Rock detail is poor, just feels brushed but with no purpose. Reminds me in that TeamPhantom kind of way.
Seems really bland and busy at the same time in other areas
Scale issue, you make things way too small.

A 0-3 does seem harsh on this track, it is a good track but when this had no delimiter from an earlier post and you have already got better features I'd have wanted more from you.

Elibloodthirst, Aug 24, 2023

#175

pawflix, Rayb25, TPlacella and 2 others like this.
loge_0 ‮‮� VIP Team Truck Team Balloon Official Author

Awarded Medals

Elibloodthirst said: ↑

NO feedback was given at the time loge_0

0-3

Pros
Intelligent layout
Looks relatively fun to play (again idk though)
Really clean in some places

Cons
Too difficult for the average user (myself included I'm shocking)
Rock detail is poor, just feels brushed but with no purpose. Reminds me in that TeamPhantom kind of way.
Seems really bland and busy at the same time in other areas
Scale issue, you make things way too small.

A 0-3 does seem harsh on this track, it is a good track but when this had no delimiter from an earlier post and you have already got better features I'd have wanted more from you.
Click to expand...

sorry but that feedback is kinda bad imo. i respect your opinion though

loge_0, Aug 24, 2023

#176

moinotchubb, gun, Coated_Badger and 3 others like this.
Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

Smh

Elibloodthirst, Aug 25, 2023

#177

moinotchubb likes this.
dzemas Well-Known Member Official Author

ye

dzemas, Aug 26, 2023

#178
Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

Awarded Medals

Super mario world by Tplacella

Ness said: ↑

yea from me, will be writing C+C with Volund for the contest. I think it's fair to feature both parts of the track
Click to expand...

spruce said: ↑

This track is massive! although not as realistic as Seasnails, this one has a charm to it. It would be easy to dismiss the scale by saying a lot of the track is copy/paste, but there are so many different sections it's definitely an impressive work. I really like the underwater and desert sections. cc would be that the ride leans a bit powerup heavy, and would have liked to see fewer stars and be a bit more resourceful with ride design. Overall its a great series that captures the spirit of the source material well. Yes.
Click to expand...

Elibloodthirst said: ↑

Pro's
Huge track
Relatively fun in most of it
relatively consistent details throughout which for something of this size is impressive
Ending is really really clean.
Impressive feat despite time constraints

Cons
Repetitive, whilst it does utilise the tool well, having 1/2 versions of a sprite for enemies does get boring quickly
Some areas lack quality, in the parts that make them unique. Not awful just not as good
I don't like the balloon to flag part of the track

Verdict: Yes for sure.

For further improvements, especially as this will be your first is to just start fine tuning some details, this has proved you have it in you.
Click to expand...

Final verdict: 4 YAY - 0 NAY

CONGRATULATIONS TPlacella

Elibloodthirst, Aug 28, 2023

#179

Seasnails, dantexpress, qduhon and 9 others like this.
SirHuman01 Well-Known Member Team Blob Official Author

YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

SirHuman01, Aug 28, 2023

#180

TPlacella and moinotchubb like this.

(You must log in or sign up to reply here.)

Page 9 of 19

Share This Page