Dismiss Notice
Hey Guest,
If you are interested in ghosting, the Ghosting Awards for January 2025 has just been announced:

Click here to check it out!

Feedback from featuring discussions

Discussion in 'Tracks' started by Ness, Feb 18, 2023.

  1. Ness

    Ness Guest

    revote
    SMITHEREENS by Nitrogeneric
    poll results: yea 3 / nay 2

     
  2. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    www.freeriderhd.com/t/976001-vita by TheCrypt + Bowlof fire 5 Yay | 2 NAY

    congratulations
     
  3. Volund

    Volund ithring VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Bay of Biscay by nasrani (https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/976883-bay-of-biscay)

    Final Vote: 7 yes, 1 no - decision, FEATURE. Congrats nas! His first feature in 9 years, and he's done it with style!

    Feedback, comments, CC:
     
    AfterImage, Cerasium, Uniior and 8 others like this.
  4. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Hi guys, another vote!

    Solar System by Seasnails https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/944191-solar-system

    I voted yes as I had spent a lot of time over the last couple weeks geeking and indulging into it more. I went through the whole thing and I just thought it was so awesome. I thought I could be over thinking it so put it forward.

    YAY 2 Nay 3

    VERDICT NO FEATURE.

    Sorry mr snails, no feature this time
     
  5. Volund

    Volund ithring VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    hey all! had an old track up for re-vote which included some (a lot of) great discussion. without further ado...

    South Dakota by StevenLeary (https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/752839-south-dakota)

    Final vote: 3 yes, 1 no - decision, FEATURE. Congrats to StevenLeary, who now earns his eighth feature - quite an achievement!

    Discussion:
     
    Last edited: Apr 10, 2024
  6. Volund

    Volund ithring VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Ramps + Portals NTBF by post2henry (https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/977830-ramps-portals-ntbf)

    Final Vote: 7 yes, 2 no - decision, FEATURE. Congrats to p2h, who earns their first feature! A huge achievement, welcome to the club :thumbsup:

    Feedback, comments, CC:
     
    Cerasium, Uniior, Eryp and 6 others like this.
  7. post2henry

    post2henry Active Member Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Thanks y'all for the feat! 2015 me would be going crazy rn haha. As for why I called the track NTBF, it's because my detailing improved drastically while making the track (I worked on it on/off for a few years) and I was too lazy to go back and fix my bad details. Maybe one day I'll find the time to truly finish the track
     
    Cerasium, waddleshoes, gun and 13 others like this.
  8. pssst

    pssst Forum Legend Elite Author Team Blob Official Author

    Awarded Medals
  9. nasrani

    nasrani Forum Legend VIP Team Blob Best Trackmaker Of 2024 Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    I thought it was generated because of how clean some of the drawings are. I love seeing a master's work transcribed to freerider; it really sets the bar for those of us who like to draw/detail. Tracing this many drawings would take forever, although it wouldn't be particularly difficult. The track isn't very well crafted. The way the drawings are integrated with the ride is pretty fun in some places but for the most part disjointed.
    I don't think a track should have to be perfect to be featured. I'm not against tracing as long as credit is given to the original artist, but if an image is traced then I expect the traced drawing to be more than just an independent image; I would hope that it would be integrated into the track in a thoughtful way.
     
  10. OdysseusSupreme

    OdysseusSupreme Certified Slowpoke Elite Author Team Balloon Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    nasrani said it well. while it is really cool, its the track as a whole isnt done well enough to justify a feat especially since its traced. not saying its gotta be perfect but integration is a must and it didnt really hit that mark
     
  11. Ness

    Ness Guest

    Double Blacks by nasrani
    poll results: yea 12 + 1 / nay 0


    congrats on the feature, and having the most positive votes for a discussion yet!
     
    Cerasium, SirHuman01, Maple and 14 others like this.
  12. nasrani

    nasrani Forum Legend VIP Team Blob Best Trackmaker Of 2024 Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Thanks so much for the kind words you guys <3<3<3<3<3<3 your thoughtful feedback means a lot
     
  13. Sltg28

    Sltg28 Well-Known Member Team Helicopter Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Max just said "i like it" GOAT :cry:
     
    Cerasium, pawflix, alexander and 2 others like this.
  14. loge_0

    loge_0 ‮‮� VIP Team Truck Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Mint Sauce by Autoa (community classic)
    https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/11105
    6 votes to 2
     
    Uniior, Cerasium, pawflix and 7 others like this.
  15. Volund

    Volund ithring VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Weem's Dream by nasrani (https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/983259-weems-dream)

    Final Vote: 9 yes (+1), 0 no - decision, FEATURE. congrats again to nas, who's been going from strength to strength this year! (waiting for mods to feat on db)

    Feedback, comments, CC:
    we have two more tracks up for discussion rn - expect more in the coming week!
     
    Uniior, Cerasium, pawflix and 7 others like this.
  16. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Hi guys,

    a really close one and potential first feature for sltg28

    https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/983302-the-less-i-know-the-better

    final verdict: 5 YAY 4 NAY

    very close, congratulation please improve on yourself as you have been and dream big!
     
  17. qduhon

    qduhon Member Official Author

    Would love to see the feedback for Gibraltar II and Landslide (congrats to the authors, by the way).
     
  18. nasrani

    nasrani Forum Legend VIP Team Blob Best Trackmaker Of 2024 Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    I loved Gibraltar II. Very consistent attention to detail and very fun ride
     
  19. Volund

    Volund ithring VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    happy to oblige ! FTR's track feedback coming next

    Gibraltar II by waddleshoes (featuring goatosaur and Embers) (https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/983451-gibraltar-ii)

    Final vote: 4 yes, 3 no - decision, FEATURE. congrats to waddleshoes and Embers, their very first features! youve both achieved something special, welcome to the club 8) and ofc, congrats to goatosaur, who nets their 2nd (i think) feature!

    Feedback, comments, CC:
    apologies if the CC is a little harsh - putting this together now, 2/3s is pretty negative :s yall have done great, even if there are easy areas to improve on in the future. nonetheless, the future of trackmaking remains bright!
     
    Last edited: Jul 15, 2024
    Uniior, Cerasium, Rayb25 and 5 others like this.
  20. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Hi Guys,

    another vote this time it is https://www.freeriderhd.com/t/983479-landslide by long time stander FTR (Flying T Rex)

    final vote: 4 YAY 0 NAY

    well deserved and well overdue can't wait to see what else you got for us moustache man
     
    Uniior, Cerasium, Rayb25 and 4 others like this.

Share This Page