Miniature circle 2024 - RESULTS

i cant tell if this is satanical or not

 

so real *sigh*

 

yeah I realized it ended 14th not 15th

 

Aint no way Eli placed his track first!

 

Oh no.


For reference id have come joint 7th

 

fyi this was my first test for the contest, its ass.

 

That looks sick.

 

Would Pay money to see a movie about this

 

Sup my homeos, awaiting is the long deserved feedback and ratings for this Miniature circle contest which I thought has done incredibly well. I am proud of you all! (Except sergio and puravida)

Show Spoiler Hide Spoiler

=1st weem - 28/30 Creativity 10 detail 10 ride 8 - This is my winner right here. Detail is fantastic, ride is fun, super creative Eli Weem 27/30 (Creativity 9 Detail 10 ride 8) May kick myself to put it at 2nd, really prime weem stuff this, great layout and top notch detail The spacebarring did me in as it doesn't feel trial like (27.5/30)
=1st Ness - Creativity 10 detail 7 ride 10 - Such an awesome entry. So creatively simple, everything works great together Ness 28/30 (Creativity 10 detail 9 ride 9) Simple yet effective. I saw this when you released it and was like nah I'd have never thought to do this in a million years. That's why you're my winner. (average 27.5/30)
3rd FTR - Creativity 10 detail 9 ride 8 - Fantastic entry. super creative, looks awesome, ride is great. FTR 26/30 (Creativity 10 detail 9 ride 7) NOW I had you for fourth origionally but this simplistic photoframed track did it for me, rides not amazing but it's relatively good usage even if you can expose it. Your best detail to date. Absolutely deserved t3 Average 26.5/30
4th Coager - 26/30 Creativity 10 detail 9 ride 7 - Super cool concept, agree that anatomy is incredibly difficult to draw. ride is a little simple, but still works - Coager 25/30 (Creativity 10 detail 9 ride 6) BRUH ZYCERAK WHEN. As someone who draws anatomy, yes this is hard af. Brilliant stuff but as you didn't fit it all in the circle I have no idea on the rest. Unlucky on the t3 just missed out. (25.5/30 average)
5th Plentitude - 26/30 Creativity 9 detail 8 ride 9 - One of my favorite entries. Ride is great, detail is clean, the dragon adds a great touch to the track. - Plentitude 24/30 (Creativity 9 detail 8 ride 7) I wish the dragon was within the circle would have added so much to it. Great track none the less. Well deserved t5 (Average 25/30)
6th Moinotchubb - 26/30 Creativity 9 detail 10 ride 7 - One of my favorites so far. Detail is fantastic, ride could be improved upon but it still works well. - Eli Creativity 8 detail 9 ride 6 - Love the ying yang on this, ride has some iffy moments and again your detail absolutely excels. Great entry. (Average 24.5/30)
7th Egona - 25/30 Creativity 8 detail 9 ride 8 - I had a good time with the ride on this track, looks great, and pretty creative. Great entry (edited) - Eli Egona 23/30 (Creativity 7 detail 8 ride 8) Simple enough, incredibly effective. Super solid entry but nothing felt enough. Very worthy of these points but you've just missed out of a t5 for me.(24/30 average)
=7th Logeton - 26/30 Creativity 9 detail 8 ride 9 - Awesome entry. The ride is fantastic, detail is clean, and creative. The ride has so many possibilities, so many different routes, so i think it deserves that high a rating - Eli logeton: 22/30 (Creativity 9 detail 5 ride 8) Crazy conception, crazier ride I think I got a cut even though my times trash af. Detail leaves a lot to be desired and cost you a potential t5 spot. (Average 24/30)
9th SkiJumping - 23/30 Creativity 9 detail 9 ride 5 - Amazing entry, looks fantastic, but the ride is luck based, which unfortunately takes away from the track - Eli SkiJumping 23/30 (Creativity 9 detail 7 ride 7) This is so essentially you. Was umming and arring about putting you top 5 and thought it just lacked slightly less detail talent to 5th. Great job SkiJumping love to see more from you. (Average 23/30)
=9th Tplacella - 24/30 Creativity 8 detail 8 ride 8 - I thought this was great. Detail is super clean, ride is pretty solid, and decently creative - tplacella 22/30 (Creativity 9 detail 7 ride 6) You've got solid detail, you've got a great mind but this just felt weird to navigate. Cool as always great job. (Average 23/30)
11th Dzemas - 25/30 Creativity 9 detail 6 ride 10 - my favorite ride so far. Great creativity, detail could be cleaned up a bit but still a great entry baltic: 19/30 (creativity 8, detail 6, ride 5) I love you tried to shoehorn me and zuza in. It's a solid track with a quite something ride. (22/30 average)
12th Awesomeman82 - 21/30 Creativity 7 detail 8 ride 6 - Pretty good entry. Looks good, ride is pretty short but not bad. - Awesomeman82: 22/30 (Creativity 6 detail 9 ride 7) Love the electrode touch, not too different creative wise it's just a hilly grassland and the rides a tad to be desired but the detail is absolutely on point. Again in the loop of the just missing out on t5. Really fantastic potential as an author. (Average 21.5/30)
13th CMLD - 21/30 Creativity 8 detail 6 ride 7 - Great use of blob, works great with the track, looks good, but the ride and detail could be cleaned up a bit (edited) - cmld 21/30 (Creativity 7 detail 6 ride 8) Really fun one one to play, one of the only decent usage of blob. Detail is incredibly scrappy, still a very good entry. (21/30 average)
14th Chugely - Creativity 7 detail 7 ride 6 - Pretty solid. Creative, yet the ride is simple and detail is super crazy - Obscurity 19/30 (Creativity 6 detail 7 ride 6) Relatively cool, not too creative but simpler and effective. Worthy of a top half finish. (19.5/30 average)
=14th Volkovo - 20/30 Creativity 6 detail 6 ride 8 - really cool auto, detail is nothing that special, pretty solid though. - Volkovo: 19/30 (Creativity 8 detail 5 ride 6) Cohesive, best use of an auto out of the two of you that had done it. Auto works, detail is simple yet effective. Good job (19.5/30 average)
15th Shadowmaster987 - 21/30 Creativity 8 detail 4 ride 9 - Great ride, cool idea, just no detail - Shadowmaster 17/30 (creativity 6, detail 2, ride 9) - This goes hard, excellent ride and concept just missing a flushed detail the small bits you have are amazing (19/30 average)
=15th qduhon - 21/30 Creativity 6 detail 7 ride 8 - Fun ride, pretty creative, detail is simple but effective - Qduhon 17/30 (Creativity 6 detail 8 ride 3) Love pagodas, just a shame it's not much more than that. Appreciate you pipping it past the post. I'd like to see more from you (19/30 average)
17th PArziv3l 18/30 Creativity 8 detail 7 ride 3 - awesome use of pixel art, ride is incredibly simple, just leaves something to be desired imoPArziv3l 19/30 (Creativity 9 detail 8 ride 2) Love the art, sweet touch. Didn't recognise if made or referenced so made it high but no points really can be made for the ride. Good job (18.5/30 average)
18th SirHuman01 - 18/30 Creativity 7 detail 7 ride 5 - shading is pretty cool, feel like the ride couldve been a lot better - Sirhuman: 18/30 (Creativity 8, detail 7, ride 3) Funny entry, with or without the other circles. Your best detail so must be rewarded however ride is very simple, too simple. Much to be imagined. (18/30 average)
=18th 4Life - 19/30 Creativity 7 detail 6 ride 6 - Cool idea, but the ride is slippery and the detail is a little messy 4life - Eli 17/30 (creativity 7, detail 6, ride 4) Hard temple of doom vibes, love what you're going for. Ride whilst utilising a lot rough and luck based at times. Your detail also needs refining. Still absolutely love this can see big things from you (18/30 average)
20th Duhchozen - 17/30 Creativity 7 detail 6 ride 4 - Ride is kinda annoying, but a creative concept. good use of different vehicles. Detail can definitely be cleaned up - Duhchozen: 18/30 (Creativity 7 detail 7 ride 4) Relatively simple concept, it's pretty cool quite rough. Rides very luck based. Could have done better if cleaner. (17.5/30 average)
21st Kamera Man - 18/30 Creativity 8 detail 7 ride 3 - Great concept, but exeucuted badly. ride is extremely janky. track still looks pretty good though - Kameraman: 16/30 (creativity 7, detail 5, ride 4) Very awesome concept, had to not withold points because it's outside the circle however the inside is fine. Pretty solid entry(17/30 average)
22nd lxcid - 16/30 Creativity 4 detail 7 ride 5 - Ride is alright, art is definitely stronger, but i like the look. pretty basic though (edited) - Lxcid 17/30 (Creativity 7, detail 6, ride 4)- I see what you did here but you've pined image over ride. Good job on the art (16.5/30)
23rd - benclayton12 - 18/30 Creativity 7 detail 5 ride 6 - lot of potential here i feel. detail is pretty rough, ride is nothing special BenClayton12 - 14/30 (Creativity 6, detail 5, ride 3) Severely rough but a good idea. You have a lot to learn young padawan. Practice drawing faces will solve you right (16/30 average)
=23rd STLG - 18/30 Creativity 7 detail 3 ride 8 - Great ride, detail is super simple though. Feel like this could've been a lot better - cky199: 14/30 (creativity 5, detail 2, ride 7) Relatively solid ride as always, non existent detail really does you in here. Sometimes less is more but here less is less. (16/30 average)
25th Guest LOL - 19/30 Creativity 7 detail 6 ride 7 - Not bad at all. Ride is decent, detail is somewhat clean, and it works pretty well - Guest lol:12/30 (4 creativity, 5 detail, 3 ride) Solid track just lacked from quality detailing (15.5/30 Average)
26th MDTajwar - 17/30 Creativity 7 detail 5 ride 5 - Again, cool idea, but not executed great. Ride isn't great, detail is messy - MDTajwar: 13/30 (creativity 4, detail 6, ride 3) Cool idea just didn't sit well with me detail wise. This has shown your potential as a freerider and I think there's more to watch from you in the future (15/30 average)
27th Ck9c - 15/30 Creativity 6 detail 7 ride 2 - Ride is actual dog ass, but shading and detail are decent - ck9c: Rides mega dog. Details rough but relatively alright. Weak concept, I'd work on smoothing out your detailing 12/30 (creativity 4, 6 detail, 2 ride) (average 13.5/30)
28th victoremmanuel - 17/30 Creativity 10 detail 6 ride 1 - so much potential here. Awesome concept, but just not executed well. the ride is ass, i didnt even bother finishing the track. such a great idea though. - VictorEmmuneal: 9/30 (5 creativity, 2 detail, 2 ride) Brilliant in Concept just incredibly weak in reality. Could do with a lot of clean up with ride and a tad bit of clean up detail. (13/30 average)
29th Plastic bike - 16/30 Creativity 7 detail 2 ride 7 - Fun ride, pretty creative, just no detail , PlasticBike: 6/30 (3 creativity 0 detail, 3 ride) Alright conceptually (11/30 average)
=29th gusthewizard - 15/30 Creativity 5 detail 2 ride 8 - Pretty solid ride here, just no detail to back it up - GusTheWizard: 7/30 (3 creativity, 1 detail, 3 ride) Actually a fun little ride but there's nothing built on it. If you had detail it would have ranked a lot higher. (11/30 average)
31st Anse - Creativity 2 detail 7 ride 1 - track looks great but no creativity with the ride, ride is the most basic you can go XanseX - 15/30 (creativity 7, detail 7, ride 1) Awesome art but can't reward it for a non ride. (12.5 average)
32nd protvod - Creativity 3 detail 1 ride 6 - Cool wheelie, but no detail or creativity protvod: protvod: 9/30 (creativity 2, detail 0, ride 7) Cool wheelie, there's nothing doing though (9.5 average)
33rd stlg28 (no xenom commentary) - Stlg28 7/30 (4 creativity, 2 detail, 1 ride): You know you'd have hit t10 easy with a finished tracks. Learn to be consistent and motivate yourself (3.5/30 average)
34th Plid - I don't even think i should judge this, its not the correct circle. 0 from Xenom Plid: 6/30 (3 creativity, 2 detail, 1 ride) Very undercooked impossible excerpt. Wasted Potential (3/30 average)
35th Puravida - agree it looks traced lol - Puravida: Don't trace. DISQUALIFIED

So we have an impasse... What does this mean?

 

IT MEANS WE HAVE A TIE BREAK.

t12 has smartly done us some feedback

Show Spoiler Hide Spoiler

For weem's track I'll go with 9/10 for detail, because I feel like among the contestants, it was one of the best. I'll go with 7/10 for the ride/usage of the track because although the usage of the track is good the upper half could have more elements and the blob parts can be a bit annoying for the ride on this, so I think a 7 is fair. For the creativity I'll go with a 8/10 because it isn't anything groundbreaking, but it's solid
So a total of 24/30

For Ness's track I'll say a solid 6/10 for detail, since it's quite simple but effective for the overall composition. I'll go with a 9/10 for the ride/usage of the track but I really like what he did here. If I split that part in two, it would be 5/5 for usage of the track and 4/5 for the ride, since it's a creative and fun ride, although it doesn't work perfectly every time and it isn't that easy to do. For creativity it's a solid 10/10. Such a simple concept, but so sick with the hexagon, the stars and the boosts
So a total of 25/30

CONGRATULATIONS NESS FOR WINNING THE COVETED GOLDEN CHEESECAKE BADGE

CONGRATULATIONS TO WEEM AND FTR FOR THE SILVER AND BRONZE CHEESECAKE BADGES

CONGRATULATIONS TO EVERYONE ELSE BUT SERGIO AND PURAVIDA (seriously who ******* cheats on a tiny circle)

I'll be back for the next one Totoca12 will assign the badges, I will DM every user for their monies donation from myself

 

homies served as roadblocks for tenth place

 

I wish contests were always like this. Simple, heaps of participants, great entries and a fast judging period. Congrats Ness for taking the W, the ride and the creativity aspect proved to be a huge factor in winning over weem.
Not sure why Ness scored so high on detail by Xenom and Eli so Weem would be my winner idk

 

can you judge this too please>> frhd.co/t/977573 my other entry. I just want to know the points

 

steaming with jealousy

 

Happily

 

6 6 4 )

 

Great contest. Very fun. Big congrats to Weem and Ness

 

I’m not happy with the results, but in all fairness, good job Ness, Weem and FTR. And thank you Eli for making a contest that didn’t flop. Very fun.

 

6/6/6 imo