Dismiss Notice
Hey Guest,
If you are interested in ghosting, the Ghosting Awards for January 2025 has just been announced:

Click here to check it out!

Classic / Official Author Discussion

Discussion in 'Anything and everything Free Rider' started by Eric, Sep 16, 2014.

  1. Eric

    Eric Administrator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator Official Author

    Hey All,

    As Free Rider HD grows we will continue to learn and make changes to the game with your input of course, one of those recent changes was around the naming of Classic to Official. We may not always agree but we do our best to make changes that we feel will be best for the community as a whole, sometimes we don't agree based on sheer effort to support something or it may not make sense for the longevity of the game.

    Classic was initially thrown in to allow for long time Free Rider players that don't necessarily ride as much anymore but still enjoy drawing tracks hence the removal of coins to upload.

    As the site has grown we have been finding that "Classic" doesn't necessarily fit anymore and "Official" is a better fit / term for the author status. "Classic" was never intended to be based on strict criteria on quality of tracks or skill of the author but instead was there to allow an author to focus on drawing as opposed to playing.

    I would really like to turn around this sentiment of negativity that has been stirring up recently, yes some authors are more skilled than others but there is no need to cut down other authors putting in time to create the best tracks they can, they will only get better with time and with constructive feedback.

    So can we try to focus on giving constructive feedback? If not, give me some reasons why and how we could bring out more constructive feedback. It is OK to disagree with something or to not like a track for one reason or another or to just simply not like someone but instead of saying someone is crap or something is crap try to give some constructive feedback on how they can improve.

    And after all that, what do you want out of this private sub-forum?
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  2. Maple

    Maple Love to draw VIP Team Balloon Trackmaker Of The Decade Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    I guess I misunderstood what the title of classic and official meant. Before I thought it was like CR's VIPs. However, since it's not based on strict criteria or skill and simply to encourage starting trackmakers then I'm cool with it.
     
  3. Eric

    Eric Administrator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator Official Author

    How did VIPs work in CR? (how did players get promoted, what did players get after being promoted, etc)
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  4. Maple

    Maple Love to draw VIP Team Balloon Trackmaker Of The Decade Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Scratch VIPs then, just thought official was for really good trackmakers
     
  5. weem

    weem FREE RIDER LEGEND Elite Author Team Blob Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Winning contests, or just getting chosen. Even though it may seem easy, most of the VIPs on CR are gods and will destroy any member here
     
  6. Max007x

    Max007x Forum Moderator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator VIP Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    VIP was pretty much the end goal for every CR player. There are 33 VIPS out of 13367 members so it was pretty exclusive. You would get VIP status after you won a contest or after you'd been making amazing tracks for a really long time. After you got promoted your name would appear orange instead of black and you would get acces to the VIP track gallery where you could make a gallery that showcased your tracks. Also you would get acces to the VIPzone which was basicly a spamhole. The status would really motivate players to make the best track they could possibly make for the contest because it was so hard to reach the rank.

    Now that you guys made clear that official author here is not the same as VIP on CR I understand why there are so many official authors. I do think that the bar shouldn't be lower than it is right now though and that you still have to earn the rank a bit. Not every single author who made more than 4 tracks should get the status.
     
  7. Maple

    Maple Love to draw VIP Team Balloon Trackmaker Of The Decade Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    ^Well since they explained it are we ever going to have something like CRs VIPs?
     
  8. Eric

    Eric Administrator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator Official Author

    Who decided would make the cut to VIP (developer, VIPs, players)? Was the recognition only on the forum, on CR itself or both?

    If we were to do something like that we would need to iron out what the criteria / nomination process would be.
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  9. Eric

    Eric Administrator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator Official Author

    Perhaps, would need to iron out what the criteria / nomination process would look like as well as the recognition.
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  10. ThreeAreFour

    ThreeAreFour Well-Known Member Official Author

    There were too many VIPs honestly and some of them didn't deserve it when the standards got higher and higher. Also, Maxi was promoted to VIP just because Maxime was a friend of his, so the title wasn't exactly definite proof that someone was one of the best.
    I think VIP would be nice here if it was a hand picked group of the best track authors, but awarding the title from a contest can easily lower the expectations of what a VIP is.
     
    Joelbmx and Elibloodthirst like this.
  11. FREEZ

    FREEZ Well-Known Member Official Author

    DOUBLE POST ALLERT haha JK
    from what it sounds like it would be a bad idea. "what classic authors should we demote" all over again
    you pagan :D
     
    Last edited: Sep 17, 2014
    ThreeAreFour likes this.
  12. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    This place should have vips tbh.
     
  13. Eric

    Eric Administrator Staff Member Administrator Forum Moderator Official Author

    If you have suggestions on how VIPs would be selected am all ears.

    Currently authors on the leaderboard are ranked by Likes + minimum rating level, is that the right motivation to create tracks that are well received by a large portion of the community?
    http://www.freeriderhd.com/leaderboards/author/lifetime/1
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  14. Cryogenic

    Cryogenic Well-Known Member Official Author

    I think it is a great motivation :thumbsup:
     
  15. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    It's good motivation but not how VIPs should work... With the amount of community you could easily have a contest right now and get a basic of maybe. 2-4 VIPs or something, make the contest last about 8 weeks. Give it a loose theme but something distinctive and I'm sure people would enter. Then give them feaches and VIP and people will crave it.
     
    Cryogenic likes this.
  16. Cryogenic

    Cryogenic Well-Known Member Official Author

    I am good, but I don't think I'll make it to VIP if there is one. :cry:
     
    Elibloodthirst likes this.
  17. Maple

    Maple Love to draw VIP Team Balloon Trackmaker Of The Decade Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    There is so much complexity that
    Since you're all ears, I don't think players should decide, too much bias and too much skill gap. If it were up to developers they'd have to have the mindset of only the best when deciding. Letting VIPs judge is good, but the issue is who decides in the beginning. I think there is always a certain trait/major aspect found in great tracks and that is if it gives you a sense of awe.
    I feel like when it comes to judging great tracks there is just so much to them that you can't simply rely on its likes,plays,etc. You really just have to take it all in by yourself and make the call.
     
    Last edited: Sep 18, 2014
    Cryogenic and Elibloodthirst like this.
  18. FREEZ

    FREEZ Well-Known Member Official Author

    I think I should decide! :D
     
  19. Elibloodthirst

    Elibloodthirst DeadRising2 VIP Team Helicopter Forum Member Of The Decade (2014-2024) Official Author

    Awarded Medals
    Honestly it should be someone who has been around and knows the game and can detail.
     
  20. FREEZ

    FREEZ Well-Known Member Official Author

    AND I WOUNDER WHO THAT WOULD BE??? SEERRRTTTANNNLY NOT ELI!!!! :D:D:D:D

    PS: I was being sarcastic
     

Share This Page